Thursday, 28 August 2014

No Best Way To Do Things :Contigency Theory

 No One Best Way To Do Things


The contingency approach is  a method of business management derived from the contingency theory . The contingency theory assumes that there is no "best way " to manage a business because businesses and situations differ to a great extent . A management approach that works for one situation may not work for another .
The contingency viewpoint focuses on management's ability to achieve alignments and good fits between employees and circumstances. This results in an employer discussing specific situations with employees to determine the best solutions to problems .






We can understand the concept of  contingency  approach with an example :
Let us consider the case of two students one with high IQ and other with low IQ . A teacher is teaching both the student . Because of their different IQ level teacher has to deal with them with different approach . First student is consistently performing in the class tests and second student finds it difficult to get atleast passing marks .
Teacher's approach to first student is to do critical analysis of his performance in tests so as to help him in achieving excellence . Whereas for second student teacher has to change his approach , he needs to motivate the second student . Despite his abysmal performance in tests teacher need to keep his motivation level high by appreciating his efforts , giving rewards etc .
By doing so teacher gains confidence and trust of second student , meanwhile teacher can work upon the weak areas of second student and help him in his studies.
Here , two different approaches are used by teacher to solve the problem .




Another example of shoe maker  :
A shoe manufacturer faced a problem of decreasing profit.
This problem can be looked from different dimensions :
from classical management theory : Time study from the belief that the decline in profit is due to lower productivity on the part of worker .
from behavioural management theory : may attempt to involve  worker more fully in decisions concerning  the methods to use in producing the shoes based on the premise that this will motivate workers to produce more .
from systems theory : may establish a committee of sales and productivity personnel to coordinate the production and distribution of goods under the assumption that large inventories are responsible for the decline in profits.
contingency approach enable the manager to examine the situation and to determine the cause of decreased profits before a new procedure or program is implemented .

Contingency theory is designed to provide the manager with the capabilities to examine numerous possible solutions to a problem .

Thursday, 21 August 2014

Theory X and Theory Y


 
Douglas McGregor (1906 -1964) was a lecturer at Harvard University and became the first Sloan Fellows Professor at MIT.

His Theory X and Theory Y was detailed in The Human Side of Enterprise, published in 1960.

 


What is it?

Essentially Theory X and Theory Y describe two opposing views of people at work that will influence management style.

Managers can be said to follow either view of their workforce.

Theory X is often said to describe a traditional view of direction and control.

Theory Y implies a more self directed workforce that takes an interest in the goals of their organisation and integrates some of their own goals into these.

 


Theory X

Theory X assumes that: -

 

The average person dislikes work and will avoid it unless directly supervised.

 

Employees must be coerced, controlled and directed to ensure that organisational objectives are met.

 

The threat of punishment must exist within an organisation.

 

In fact people prefer to be managed in this way so that they avoid responsibility.

 

Theory X assumes that people are relatively unambitious and their prime driving force is the desire for security.

 

Theory Y

Theory Y effectively takes the opposite view.

 

It assumes that: -

 

Employees are ambitious, keen to accept greater responsibility and exercise both self-control and direction.

 

Employees will, in the right conditions, work toward organisational objectives and that commitment will in itself be a reward for so doing.

 


Employees will exercise their imagination and creativity in their jobs if given the chance and this will give an opportunity for greater productivity.

 

Theory Y assumes that the average human being will, under the right conditions, not only accept responsibility but also seek more.

 

Lack of ambition and the qualities of Theory X are not inherent human characteristics but learned in working environments that suffocate or do not promote Theory Y behaviours.

 

Links with Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs

Abraham Maslow viewed John McGregor as a mentor and was a supporter of his theory and each utilised each other's theories in their own work.

McGregor grouped Maslow's hierarchy into 'lower order' Theory X needs and 'higher order' Theory Y needs, suggesting that those behaviours at the top of his hierarchy linked with Theory Y behaviours.

 


Criticism of Theory X / Theory Y

Nowadays McGregor's theory is seen as outdated, representing two extremes.

Theory X is perhaps visible in low paid or menial work but employees in those situations will move on in search of positions with Theory Y conditions if they are motivated.

Personal development, management training and even general perceptions of behaviour are against a Theory X outlook towards work.

There is no doubt that this outlook would have been more prevalent in the 1960s when McGregor created his theory.

Before he died McGregor started working on a new Theory that he called Theory Z to address these criticisms.

Unfortunately he died before this could be widely published and the ideas have since faded from mainstream management theory.

They were, however, landmark ideas at their time and now form an important part of the historical study of management theory.

 

Sunday, 10 August 2014

My Life Time Experience at Maha Mandi

 

The event started with the much awaited and lively inauguration where the chief guests and students not only from NITIE but from across several other top b-schools in masses created the buzz out of the event. Our journey started when the bus droped us at Andheri Station and we took the exclusive Mumbai’s local which has the second busiest rapid transit in the world. And as expected it was overcrowded with the daily commuters and with a little struggle we managed to board it finally.

 


1)      As soon as we found a place to sit we thought about starting the selling. But unfortunately it was a wrong call. As we as we started pitching our products people started ignoring us and started moving away. And some of them even asked us not to irritate them and they just wanted to travel quietly.
 

2)      Though it was an unproductive attempt but it definitely warmed us up to target our next customer. And we met this Marathi women outside the Churchgate railway station and we started pitching about Tangram. She was not looking interested initially but when we mentioned the social cause of the event her eyes sparkled and she asked her husband to buy our product.

3)      The sale of our first product gave us all the warmth and confidence in the world and we decided to target the appropriate audience at appropriate place and moved to gateway of India. We approached a couple who was sitting with their kid and with all the eagerness and devotion we introduced our next production to them and within a blink of an eye they agreed to buy our product.


4)      There were times when we faced some rejections but it didn’t hinder our way to reach the huge crowd that was present at the gateway of India. We started feeling like we have become the master of sellers and have actually learned the marketing concepts though selling on our own. It was Street selling only which gave birth to the marketing concepts and here we are who finally learned and earned by applying those concepts.
 
 
 
 

5)      Our confidence was getting intense with every product we were selling. So we decided to sell our last few products to some not so easy targets and then we pitched our products to the honourable and righteous Mumbai police officers. And guess what, even those tough and noble officers didn’t bereft themselves in the contribution for the unprivileged children. It was really a heart touching and saccharine experience


 

Indeed it was my unique and lifetime experience. Maha Mandi was really an enduring and eventful experience which enriched me with some extraordinary and unusual learning.

Special thanks to Mandi Sir who took this initiative of engaging students from all across the city to engage in street selling for a noble cause .

 

Thursday, 31 July 2014

IM21_SagarArora_139:A Brief Look At Charismatic Leadership


 

The purpose of this short article is to give you a bite-sized insight into charismatic leadership.  So what is charismatic leadership?

It’s the name given to a particular leadership style – in other words, it describes the behaviour of a certain category of leaders.

The term “charismatic leadership” draws on the word “charisma”, which comes from the Greek language and means “gift”.

Thus, charismatic leadership relies on a leader’s personality gifts to influence others and shape their future.  Such gifts can include great wisdom or insight, heroism, extraordinary certainty about the future and perhaps even the claim of a direct link to God.

However, charismatic leadership demands more than just an exceptional personality.

Followers & Charismatic Leadership

You see, those who follow the charismatic leader must also project an image of specialness and authority on to him and give him power over them.

Therefore charismatic leadership relies on the twin effect of a leader’s personality and a strong belief by followers that this special person is the one to lead them in their hour of need.

Charismatic Leadership & The Moral Dimension

In Weber’s view, charismatic leadership had no moral dimension – it could be a force for good or evil.

Using his definition, the only question is: do the followers grant authority to the leader based on their view of his or her special gifts?  If the answer is yes, this is charismatic leadership.

So although this may horrify many, Adolf Hitler was as much a charismatic leader as Jesus Christ.

Dangers of Charismatic Leadership

Charismatic leadership can be effective in the sense that it can cause swift change.  However it has dangers.

·         It can be used for evil ends

·         It can create dependency among followers – causing them to take less responsibility for themselves

·         It can encourage a belief in the leader’s infallibility to the point where the leader is allowed to make foolish decisions

·         And it can take followers down a blind alley if the seemingly charismatic leader proves to have more style than substance

·    
Charismatic Leadership, Instability & Personality Cults

Despite these dangers, charismatic leadership can be unstable and short lived.

This is because charismatic leaders can only stay in power while their followers continue to believe in their specialness.  If they disappoint their followers in some way, perhaps because they reveal previously hidden flaws or fail to deliver, this belief can fade – draining charismatic leaders of their authority.

To guard against this risk, charismatic leadership may involve a cult of personality to stop followers realising that their leader is less impressive than they think.

Wednesday, 23 July 2014

THE UNIQUE AND INDIVIDUALISTIC APPROACH

 
Joining NITIE is one of the most amazing things that have happened to me. Being located at the heart of the city, isolated from the hustle bustles of the city and surrounded with the God’s natural greenery really makes it the GOD’S own campus. The relentless rain, sleepless nights with empty stomach and hectic schedule are the things that I have always imagined about NITIE before coming here and this is something that I have already started enjoying.


 
But the unconventional ways of Dr. Prasad in the OB & HR class was something beyond my imagination. Dr.Prasad, popularly known as Professor Mandi has his own innovative and unique ways of leanings.  He believes in spreading knowledge and developing business acumen among all through his own unconventional ways. What makes his methods unconventional is the way he demonstrates the crucial concepts in a simple and effective way.

May it be tower building to understand co-operation between people, or the three monks video to understand team work, the magic cube to understand how squares and cubes were derived to designing posters to understand what can catch the eye!

 


 

Professor’s unconventional methods go a long way in helping us understand “management concepts”. And it really doesn't feel like a burden to learn these concepts. This helps us grasp the concepts in our heads the first time itself and the hands on experience ensures that we understand their application in the real world scenario.




 

It’s really fascinating when you get such kind of learning in a premier B-School like NITIE. Certainly I would say the journey has just started and I am sure that this journey will definitely put us through a lot of legendary things that are yet to come.